This is a source-backed record of a public case and my opinion about it. These are the laws and court decisions behind that.
The First Amendment
U.S. Constitution, Amendment I
Congress and the states can't punish speech or the press on matters of public concern just because the people being written about don't like it. Nolan's death, the investigation and the grand jury are matters of public concern.
Constitution Annotated
Speech on Public Issues Gets Special Protection
Snyder v. Phelps, 562 U.S. 443 (2011)
The Supreme Court held that speech on public issues sits on the "highest rung" of First Amendment values and "cannot be restricted simply because it is upsetting or arouses contempt."
Justia
Opinion Is Protected
Milkovich v. Lorain Journal Co., 497 U.S. 1 (1990)
A statement of opinion on a matter of public concern that doesn't contain a provably false fact gets full constitutional protection. On this site, opinion is labeled as analysis and sits next to the sourced facts it's built on.
Justia
Public Figures Have to Prove Actual Malice
New York Times Co. v. Sullivan, 376 U.S. 254 (1964)
A public figure suing over speech has to prove it was published knowing it was false or with reckless disregard for the truth, and has to prove it with "convincing clarity."
Justia Oyez
Stepping Into a Public Controversy
Gertz v. Robert Welch, Inc., 418 U.S. 323 (1974)
Someone who "voluntarily injects himself" into a public controversy becomes a public figure for that controversy. In my view, the friends did that when they went public and filed defamation lawsuits over this case.
Justia AP News
Truth
A complete defense to defamation
Truth is an absolute defense to defamation, and minor errors don't matter as long as the gist is true. Every fact on this site links to its source so anyone can check it.
Digital Media Law Project
Fair Report Privilege
Reporting on official records and proceedings
Fairly and accurately reporting what's in official documents, court filings and statements by officials is privileged, as long as the source is named. That covers the grand jury report, the DA's letters and the court filings in the Record Library.
Digital Media Law Project
Republishing What Others Posted
47 U.S.C. § 230(c)(1); Barrett v. Rosenthal (Cal. 2006)
No "user of an interactive computer service" can be treated as the publisher of information someone else provided. California's Supreme Court held this protects individuals who republish other people's content online.
U.S. Code Barrett v. Rosenthal
Fair Use of Photos, Video and Screenshots
17 U.S.C. § 107
Using copyrighted material for "criticism, comment, news reporting" and research is fair use. Photos, interview frames and screenshots here are used to document and comment on the case.
U.S. Code U.S. Copyright Office
Public Records Are Public Property
Mississippi Public Records Act of 1983, Miss. Code § 25-61-1
Mississippi law says public records "must be available for inspection by any person." Records obtained that way can be shared.
Mississippi Code Mississippi Ethics Commission
Anti-SLAPP Laws
California, Texas, New York, Florida, Washington and other states
Many states have anti-SLAPP laws that let a court quickly throw out a lawsuit aimed at speech on a public issue. Many of them also make the person who filed the lawsuit pay the defendant's attorney's fees.
California Texas New York Florida Washington