Phone & Keys

They Kept His Phone and Keys

They took Nolan's phone and keys and never gave them back. His mom had to track the phone down herself.

The Phone

Everyone left their phones on the boat that day, scattered across the console. Nolan last unlocked his around 2:18 p.m. New York Magazine

When the Triton left Horn Island at 4:31 p.m., Nolan's phone went with it. He didn't. MDMR GPS summary

The friends' own lawyer, J. Tyler Cox, says a girl from the group gathered all the phones from the boat and put them in Wyatt Pyron's truck, and that Nolan's phone "stayed there until Christine's friend came over to get Nolan's phone" around 1:30 a.m. TMZ

At 11:49 p.m. on July 4, Nolan's mother told dispatch that her son was missing and that his phone was in a friend's truck. MDMR report The family found it with Life360. The Cut Family friend Tashema Hands went to get it. She said it took his friends 15 minutes to find it. New York Magazine

Analysis

Nobody from that boat brought Nolan's phone to his mother. It sat in a truck for hours while Nolan was missing, and it only came back because his family tracked it and went to get it. That is not "giving it back."

The Keys

Nolan left his keys on top of the Xbox. New York Magazine According to Nolan's father, Jax Pitalo told him, "I don't see the keys." They turned up only after someone called a girl who remembered they were on top of the Xbox. WLOX video of the family's remarks

The friends' lawyers later put it in writing: Nolan "had left his keys in Pitalo's bedroom." CNN

What Officials Did with the Phone

On Aug. 12, the district attorney sent the family a letter, while they were out of state, demanding the phone in less than 48 hours. The Clarion Ledger found three different versions of how the phone was retrieved. Clarion Ledger

The grand jury said Nolan's phone "was not the only phone to travel back to the mainland." Grand jury report

The family's examiner, Garrett Discovery, found that Snapchat messages were recalled and deleted from Nolan's phone between his last unlock and the early hours of July 5. People The DA answered that the deletions came "from other snapchat users, not someone physically accessing Nolan Wells' phone." TMZ

Analysis

Both of those things can be true, and neither helps the friends. If other Snapchat users pulled their messages back after Nolan went missing, then someone in his circle was erasing what they had sent him. Who, and why, is exactly what an investigation should answer.

Read the messages archive